San Francisco Police’s Drone Dilemma: Breaking Laws to Fight Crime

San Francisco have been using drones to catch car break-in suspects and investigate sideshows for months, but internal emails reveal the department knowingly broke the law by purchasing these crime-fighting tools. Now, the SFPD is asking city leaders to approve the drones retroactively, after ignoring warnings from within its own ranks, reports The San Francisco Standard.

Unauthorized Drone Purchases

About a week before the March 5 election, the SFPD was planning which drones to buy if voters expanded police powers by passing Proposition E. However, one of its own experts, Asja Steeves, the SFPD policy division manager, cautioned that Prop. E alone did not grant the department authority to add drones to its arsenal. Steeves wrote in a Feb. 28 email, “Prop. E does not supersede state law,” referring to Assembly Bill 481, which requires police to get approval from city elected officials before using new surveillance tools.

Legal Concerns and Political Controversy

Steeves also warned that rushing to buy drones could put the SFPD in the middle of a political controversy.

“If we want to stay out of the political fray and buy drones in order to use them in efficient ways that help the department, we may want to wait until after the election to start the AB 481 approval process,” she advised.

Despite these warnings, the top brass didn’t wait. Prop. E passed, drones were bought, and the SFPD began openly touting its new gadgets.

Drone Use and Legal Implications

The SFPD’s drones have already captured car break-in suspects on camera, but civil liberties advocates argue that the department is now scrambling to get into compliance with state law.

Matt Guariglia, a policy analyst with the Electronic Frontier Foundation, said the department is trying to quietly correct a mistake it knew full well it was making.

“This email from Feb. 28 is kind of a smoking gun,” he said. “Their own policy person told them ahead of time to pump the brakes on the drones because they’d need prior approval, yet they immediately started buying these drones despite that warning. Everything they did afterwards was in violation of state law.”

Retroactive Approval Attempt

The SFPD is now seeking retroactive approval through a proposal from Supervisor Matt Dorsey, a former police communications boss. Acting Lt. Eric Batchelder highlighted the benefits of drone use, stating that the department has six drones that were used in 65 missions, 18 of which led to arrests.

However, Supervisor Shamann Walton raised concerns similar to those of the EFF, questioning whether the current drone use is in violation of state law.

Legal and Ethical Dilemmas

John Lindsay-, an activist and writer advocating for demilitarizing the police, noted that the SFPD appears to be the only agency in to use drones without prior approval since AB 481 became law.

“A law enforcement agency violating the law sets a bad example for the community and puts at risk the prosecutions in which drones were used,” he said.

DroneXL’s Take

The use of drones by the SFPD highlights the complexities of integrating new technology into law enforcement. While drones offer significant benefits in crime-fighting, the legal and ethical considerations cannot be overlooked. As we see in this case, the lack of proper approval can lead to legal challenges and public scrutiny.

For more insights into the use of drones in law enforcement, check out our recent articles on police drones and first responders.

What are your thoughts on this article? Leave your comments below.

Photo courtesy of the San Francisco Police Department.


Khám phá thêm từ DroneXL.co

Đăng ký để nhận các bài đăng mới nhất được gửi đến email của bạn.

MAKE YOUR VOICE HEARD

Proposed legislation threatens your ability to use drones for fun, work, and safety. The Drone Advocacy Alliance is fighting to ensure your voice is heard in these critical policy discussions.Join us and tell your elected officials to protect your right to fly.

Drone Advocacy Alliance
TAKE ACTION NOW
Follow us on Google News!

Get your Part 107 Certificate

Pass the test and take to the skies with the Pilot Institute. We have helped thousands of people become airplane and commercial drone pilots. Our courses are designed by industry experts to help you pass FAA tests and achieve your dreams.

pilot institute dronexl

Copyright © DroneXL.co 2024. All rights reserved. The content, images, and intellectual property on this website are protected by copyright law. Reproduction or distribution of any material without prior written permission from DroneXL.co is strictly prohibited. For permissions and inquiries, please contact us first. Also, be sure to check out DroneXL's sister site, EVXL.co, for all the latest news on electric vehicles.

FTC: DroneXL.co is an Amazon Associate and uses affiliate links that can generate income from qualifying purchases. We do not sell, share, rent out, or spam your email.

Haye Kesteloo
Haye Kesteloo

Haye Kesteloo is the Editor in Chief and Founder of DroneXL.co, where he covers all drone-related news, DJI rumors and writes drone reviews, and EVXL.co, for all news related to electric vehicles. He is also a co-host of the PiXL Drone Show on YouTube and other podcast platforms. Haye can be reached at haye @ dronexl.co or @hayekesteloo.

Bài viết: 4069

Gửi phản hồi

Website này sử dụng Akismet để hạn chế spam. Tìm hiểu bình luận của bạn được duyệt như thế nào.

viVietnamese