Shaker Heights Debates Police Drone Purchase Amid Safety and Privacy Concerns

Debate Continues Over Police Department Request for Drones

The Shaker Heights City Council continues to debate the department's request to purchase a $30,000 drone using forfeiture money. The discussion gained new urgency following a recent standoff involving an armed suspect, reports, highlighting the potential benefits and concerns surrounding drone use.

A Standoff Demonstrates Drone Utility

This past Sunday, police were involved in a standoff outside a Shaker Heights apartment complex in with an armed man linked to the shooting death of Euclid police officer Jacob Derbin. During the incident, drones on loan were deployed to gather intelligence, which was crucial for the responding officers.

“We saw the drone's importance in handling the incident this weekend,” retired Willoughby Assistant Fire Chief Scott Mlakar told the council. The drones provided immediate intelligence, allowing officers to stay safe on the ground. “Rather than sending police in, the drone goes looking for an armed suspect,” Mlakar said, emphasizing that drones can act as “de-escalation and situational awareness tools.”

Safety vs. Privacy: The Ongoing Debate

Shaker Police Chief Wayne Hudson supports the drone purchase, citing officer safety in high-risk situations. However, some council members remain wary of public sector drone applications, concerned about privacy and Fourth Amendment rights. Councilman Sean Malone expressed the potential for abuse, despite public safety agencies being regulated by oversight commissions.

Jason Lorenzon from Kent State University addressed the council on aspects of drone law, advocating for collaboration with the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) to establish proper legislation. “You either legislate things into existence, or you litigate them later,” Lorenzon remarked.

Finding Common Ground

Mayor David Weiss suggested looking at other communities' legislation to guide Shaker Heights' policies. Councilman Ifeolu A.C. Claytor recommended evaluating similar communities' policies to inform their decisions. Meanwhile, Councilwoman Nancy Moore inquired about continuing to use guidelines set by Lexipol, an organization providing standardized policies and training for law enforcement.

Vice Mayor Carmella Williams stressed the need to balance giving useful tools while addressing privacy concerns. The council also plans to seek input from the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) and Policy Matters Ohio.

As Shaker Heights City Council deliberates the police department's request for a drone, the debate balances the critical safety benefits against potential privacy infringements. The recent standoff illustrated the practical advantages of drones, but the council must carefully consider legislative and ethical guidelines to protect the community's rights while enhancing public safety.

Discover more from DroneXL

Subscribe to get the latest posts to your email.


Proposed legislation threatens your ability to use drones for fun, work, and safety. The Drone Advocacy Alliance is fighting to ensure your voice is heard in these critical policy discussions.Join us and tell your elected officials to protect your right to fly.

Drone Advocacy Alliance
Follow us on Google News!

Get your Part 107 Certificate

Pass the test and take to the skies with the Pilot Institute. We have helped thousands of people become airplane and commercial drone pilots. Our courses are designed by industry experts to help you pass FAA tests and achieve your dreams.

pilot institute dronexl

Copyright © 2024. All rights reserved. The content, images, and intellectual property on this website are protected by copyright law. Reproduction or distribution of any material without prior written permission from is strictly prohibited. For permissions and inquiries, please contact us first.

FTC: is an Amazon Associate and uses affiliate links that can generate income from qualifying purchases. We do not sell, share, rent out, or spam your email.

Haye Kesteloo
Haye Kesteloo

Haye Kesteloo is the Editor in Chief and Founder of, where he covers all drone-related news, DJI rumors and writes drone reviews, and, for all news related to electric vehicles. He is also a co-host of the PiXL Drone Show on YouTube and other podcast platforms. Haye can be reached at haye @ or @hayekesteloo.

Articles: 3484

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.